Are Used Golf Balls as Good as New?

Sharing is caring!

If you’re an avid golfer, you’ve probably wondered whether used golf balls can perform just as well as new ones.

After all, golf balls can be expensive, and buying used or refurbished options could save you a significant amount of money. But is it worth it? Do used golf balls affect your distance, spin, and overall game?

In this detailed guide, you’ll learn:

• The different types of used golf balls and their conditions
• How used balls compare to new ones in performance, durability, and feel
• Whether buying used golf balls is a smart investment
• Who should (and shouldn’t) use them
• The best ways to test used golf balls for quality

By the end of this article, you’ll have all the information you need to decide whether used golf balls are a worthy alternative to new ones.

---

Used Golf Balls: What Are Your Options?

Not all used golf balls are created equal. They come in different conditions and categories, and their performance can vary widely depending on how they’ve been used, stored, or refurbished.

Here are the main types of used golf balls:

Recycled Golf Balls

Recycled golf balls are those that have been retrieved from golf courses, lakes, or rough areas and then cleaned up. They have not been altered in any way beyond cosmetic cleaning.

✅ Pros:

• Typically cheaper than new balls
• Performance is close to new if the ball was lightly used
• Environmentally friendly

❌ Cons:

• Some balls may have scuffs or minor imperfections
• Might be difficult to find a consistent batch of matching models

---

Refurbished (Refinished) Golf Balls

Refurbished golf balls go through a repainting and refinishing process, giving them a like-new appearance. They are often retrieved from water hazards, cleaned, repainted, and stamped with a fresh logo.

✅ Pros:

• Look almost brand new
• More affordable than new golf balls
• Easier to find matching sets

❌ Cons:

• The refinishing process may alter performance
• The new paint can make the ball less durable
• Inconsistent quality—some refinished balls have layers removed or added

---

Lake Balls (Water Balls)

Lake balls are golf balls that have been sitting in water hazards for an extended period before being recovered. Depending on how long they were submerged, they may have absorbed moisture, affecting their performance.

✅ Pros:

• Very affordable
• Often retrieved from popular premium brands

❌ Cons:

• Water exposure can affect compression and distance
• Older lake balls may lose their structural integrity
• Performance varies depending on how long they were underwater

---

Used vs. New Golf Balls

Now that you know the different types of used golf balls, let’s compare them to new ones across various performance categories.

Distance

Distance is one of the biggest concerns when it comes to using second-hand golf balls.

• New golf balls are designed with perfectly balanced cores and smooth outer covers, ensuring maximum energy transfer for distance.
• Used golf balls (especially lake balls) may have lost compression due to age, damage, or water absorption, reducing their distance by a few yards.
• Recycled balls that have only been lightly used typically retain their original distance.

🔹 Verdict: If you buy mint-condition recycled balls, they should perform nearly identically to new balls in terms of distance. However, lake balls or refinished balls may lead to noticeable yardage loss.

---

Spin & Control

Spin is critical for shot-shaping and greenside control.

• New balls have a fresh, perfectly intact urethane or ionomer cover, which helps maintain maximum spin on wedge shots.
• Refurbished balls often have repainted covers, which can make them feel slicker and reduce spin.
• Recycled balls in good condition usually retain most of their original spin, but scuffs and wear can impact greenside control.

🔹 Verdict: If spin and control are essential to your game, you should avoid refinished balls and stick with high-quality recycled balls that haven’t been overly damaged.

---

Feel & Compression

Golf ball feel is particularly important for short-game shots and putting.

• New golf balls are designed with precise compression ratings for optimal feel and feedback.
• Used balls that have been stored properly will often feel almost the same as new.
• Refinished balls may have thicker paint layers, affecting feel and making them slightly harder.

🔹 Verdict: If you play a soft-feel ball like Callaway Supersoft or Titleist Pro V1, stick with high-grade recycled balls instead of refinished ones.

---

Durability & Longevity

Durability is where new golf balls have a clear edge.

• New golf balls last longer because they have fresh covers and cores.
• Recycled balls that are in mint condition can last almost as long as new ones.
• Refinished balls may have thicker paint or weaker outer layers, leading to faster wear and tear.

🔹 Verdict: New balls will always be the most durable, but recycled balls in good condition can last multiple rounds without issues.

---

Should You Buy Used Golf Balls?

Used golf balls aren’t for everyone, but they can be a great option depending on your playing level and budget.

✅ You SHOULD Buy Used Golf Balls If:

✔️ You’re a beginner or high-handicap golfer who loses a lot of balls.
✔️ You want to save money without sacrificing too much performance.
✔️ You don’t need tour-level spin and control.
✔️ You don’t mind using slightly worn or cosmetically imperfect balls.

🚫 You Should AVOID Used Golf Balls If:

❌ You play competitively or in tournaments, where ball consistency is key.
❌ You rely on high-spin shots and precision control.
❌ You want maximum durability for extended play.
❌ You’re using a high-performance ball like Titleist Pro V1—you may notice more performance loss.

---

How to Choose the Best Used Golf Balls

If you’re going to buy used golf balls, follow these tips to get the best quality:

✔️ Buy “mint” or “near-mint” condition balls – These are the closest to new in performance.
✔️ Avoid refinished balls – They may look great, but their performance can be inconsistent.
✔️ Check for scuffs, cuts, and discoloration – These can indicate wear or internal damage.
✔️ Buy from reputable sellers – Stick with trusted golf retailers instead of random bulk sellers.
✔️ Consider bulk purchases – Buying in larger quantities can save you even more money.

---

Are Used Golf Balls as Good as New?

Depending on their condition, used golf balls can be nearly as good as new ones.

If you choose high-quality recycled balls, you can enjoy almost the same distance, spin, and feel for a fraction of the price.

However, if you play competitively or need precise control, you’re better off sticking with new golf balls.

Bottom Line: If you’re looking to save money while still enjoying great performance, mint-condition used golf balls are a smart choice.

Just make sure to avoid refinished balls and those with visible damage.

So, next time you’re shopping for golf balls, don’t hesitate to try some used ones—you might be surprised at how well they perform! ⛳